Hi Zachrbert1
Thanks for the update.
To correct the situation, I would recommend to check the Payroll Details > Employment details > Make sure that the Default pay slip delivery is set to To be emailed. Also, please check the Payroll Settings > Pay slip email defaults. Make sure to set up the From name and Reply-to email address correctly. Once done, please try to email the pay slips to the employees.
Please let me know how it goes.
If my response has answered your enquiry please click "Accept as Solution" to assist other users find this information.
Best regards,
Doreen